Discussion:
Gabriel Opened Muhammad's Chest ...
(too old to reply)
David Amicus
2015-10-12 22:43:01 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
And took out his heart and washed it removing a small part that belonged to=
Satan?

http://turntoislam.com/community/threads/gabriel-opened-muhammads-pbu-chest=
-and-took-out-his-heart.51525/

Muhammad was holy, perfect, pure. There must have been another reason. Wha=
t?

Maybe to strengthen him for his mission as the universal Prophet? Unlike ot=
her prophets Muhammad's entire life - words, actions, deeds - were to be ke=
pt as examples to follow. His life was a model, an example for everyone to =
follow. The Message can not be separated from the Messenger!
Yusuf B Gursey
2015-10-13 06:01:46 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
On Tuesday, October 13, 2015 at 12:50:03 AM UTC+3, David Amicus wrote:

David, these miracle stories are later additions. This is the Qur'anic posi=
tion, from Enc. of Qur'an "Muhammad":

<<
=20
The constant human nature of the Prophet prevents him from complying with t=
he demands for miracles, and when this demand is made, God commands his mes=
senger to say that the unseen (ghayb) belongs to God alone ( q 10:20). This=
seems to mean that he is but a mortal messenger who cannot perform superna=
tural acts of his own volition. Only God has the power to produce signs, as=
the Qur=CA=BE=C4=81n itself states elsewhere ( q 6:37, etc.), and it is fo=
r him to decide whom he wishes to guide ( q 13:27). Previous prophets are p=
ut in the same situation when commanded to produce signs, and they too answ=
er that they are but mortals and that they can only produce miracles with G=
od's permission ( q 14:10-11).
The public miracle granted in the Qur'an by God to Muhammad is the Qur'an i=
tself. the only other miracle for which there is agreemnt among Muslim scho=
lars in the Qur'an is the Night Jorurney to Jerusalem and the ascent to Hea=
ven from there. This is a personal miracle that God grants to Muhammad for =
his own edification. The Splitting of the Moon has been debated and again, =
in the Sirah or biography of the Prophet this is seen by only a few people =
other than Muhammad.
And took out his heart and washed it removing a small part that belonged=
=20
to=3D
Satan?
=20
http://turntoislam.com/community/threads/gabriel-opened-muhammads-pbu-che=
st=3D
-and-took-out-his-heart.51525/
=20
Muhammad was holy, perfect, pure. There must have been another reason.=
=20
Wha=3D
t?
=20
Maybe to strengthen him for his mission as the universal Prophet? Unlike =
ot=3D
her prophets Muhammad's entire life - words, actions, deeds - were to be =
ke=3D
pt as examples to follow. His life was a model, an example for everyone t=
o =3D
follow. The Message can not be separated from the Messenger!
Loading...