Discussion:
Sunnis And The 12th Imam
(too old to reply)
David Amicus
2016-01-14 23:07:04 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
I had thought that only the Shi'ites and then only the Twelvers had an interest in the 12th Imam.

Across the street from me several years ago there was a kebab shop. The owner was an Afghani. He said that he was a descendant of Ali from a wife not Fatima. He had a great interest in Sufism. I forget now who but a contemporary.

This shop owner said that he was a Sunni but he had a belief in the 12th Imam.

Why would a Sunni be interested in the 12th Imam?
Yusuf B Gursey
2016-01-15 12:42:22 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by David Amicus
I had thought that only the Shi'ites and then only the Twelvers had an interest in the 12th Imam.
Across the street from me several years ago there was a kebab shop. The owner was an Afghani. He said that he was a descendant of Ali from a wife not Fatima. He had a great interest in Sufism. I forget now who but a contemporary.
This shop owner said that he was a Sunni but he had a belief in the 12th Imam.
Why would a Sunni be interested in the 12th Imam?
Sufi orders are sometimes syncretic.
Fariduddien
2016-01-16 11:38:35 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Yusuf B Gursey
Post by David Amicus
I had thought that only the Shi'ites and then only the Twelvers had an interest in the 12th Imam.
Across the street from me several years ago there was a kebab shop. The owner was an Afghani. He said that he was a descendant of Ali from a wife not Fatima. He had a great interest in Sufism. I forget now who but a contemporary.
This shop owner said that he was a Sunni but he had a belief in the 12th Imam.
Why would a Sunni be interested in the 12th Imam?
Sufi orders are sometimes syncretic.
Salam,

There are both Sunnis and Shi`ah in Afghanistan. I
think the Shi`ah in Afghanistan are mostly those
of the Hazara ethnic group.

It is important for Sunnis to respect the Prophet's
(s.a.w.) family, and of course, the Imams of Twelver
Shi`ism were all his descendents (through Fatima,
who was Ali's wife until her death).

Some Sunnis (particularly among some Sufi groups)
may interpret this as respecting the Imams of
Twelver Shi`ism as descendents of the Prophet
(s.a.w.).

For example, there is a recording of the Khalwati
(Halveti) tariqa in Turkey, who are Sunni,
performing dhikr (remembrance of Allah) on the
anniversary of the battle of Kerbala, where Husain,
the grandson of the Prophet (s.a.w.), was killed.
Husain is also considered by Twelver Shi`ah as
the 3rd Imam.

Jafar as-Sadiq is respected and praised by many
Sunni sources, and he is also considered by Twelver
Shi`ah as the 6th Imam.

However, I am not aware of Sunnis believing in the
12th Imam as the Twelver Shi`ah do. Sunni Islam
does believe in the coming of the Mahdi, but while
there are clues in the hadiths, the exact identity
of who the Mahdi will be is not known.

Without knowing more, I think it is impossible to
really know how your friend came to his belief.
Possibly he was influenced by Shi`ah family or
friends, that could be one possibility.

As for syncretic Sufi groups, the Bektashi are
sometimes considered to be such a group, but to my
knowledge they are not really known in Afghanistan.
They are known, to my knowledge, mainly in Albania
and Turkey.
Yusuf B Gursey
2016-01-17 10:45:17 UTC
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Fariduddien
Post by Yusuf B Gursey
Post by David Amicus
I had thought that only the Shi'ites and then only the Twelvers had an interest in the 12th Imam.
Across the street from me several years ago there was a kebab shop. The owner was an Afghani. He said that he was a descendant of Ali from a wife not Fatima. He had a great interest in Sufism. I forget now who but a contemporary.
This shop owner said that he was a Sunni but he had a belief in the 12th Imam.
Why would a Sunni be interested in the 12th Imam?
Sufi orders are sometimes syncretic.
Salam,
There are both Sunnis and Shi`ah in Afghanistan. I
think the Shi`ah in Afghanistan are mostly those
of the Hazara ethnic group.
It is important for Sunnis to respect the Prophet's
(s.a.w.) family, and of course, the Imams of Twelver
Shi`ism were all his descendents (through Fatima,
who was Ali's wife until her death).
Some Sunnis (particularly among some Sufi groups)
may interpret this as respecting the Imams of
Twelver Shi`ism as descendents of the Prophet
(s.a.w.).
For example, there is a recording of the Khalwati
(Halveti) tariqa in Turkey, who are Sunni,
performing dhikr (remembrance of Allah) on the
anniversary of the battle of Kerbala, where Husain,
the grandson of the Prophet (s.a.w.), was killed.
Husain is also considered by Twelver Shi`ah as
the 3rd Imam.
The event is remembered throughout Turkey by eating
of a certain gruel said to have associated with the
event as well as with Noah. Mosques have the names
of Hasan and Husayn, after Allah, Muhammad and the
four caliphs.
Post by Fariduddien
Jafar as-Sadiq is respected and praised by many
Sunni sources, and he is also considered by Twelver
Shi`ah as the 6th Imam.
However, I am not aware of Sunnis believing in the
12th Imam as the Twelver Shi`ah do. Sunni Islam
does believe in the coming of the Mahdi, but while
there are clues in the hadiths, the exact identity
of who the Mahdi will be is not known.
Without knowing more, I think it is impossible to
really know how your friend came to his belief.
Possibly he was influenced by Shi`ah family or
friends, that could be one possibility.
As for syncretic Sufi groups, the Bektashi are
sometimes considered to be such a group, but to my
knowledge they are not really known in Afghanistan.
They are known, to my knowledge, mainly in Albania
and Turkey.
Loading...